During the early 20th century, the Kukelhan Mansion belonged to Mr. and Mrs. Frederick Kukelhan, the property’s namesake. They lived there with their seven children, one girl and six boys.
In November 1907, the couple was on their way to visit some friends in New Haven, Indiana when tragedy struck. While passing through the small village of Maples, Indiana, they were killed when their buggy was hit by a Pennsylvania Railroad train. Following their untimely demise, the children continued to reside on the property, leaving their daughter, the eldest child, to raise her brothers.
It is said that anyone who attempted to live in the house had to leave due to the paranormal activity they experienced there.
Several sources claim a much more sensational story, stating that the Kukelhan Mansion belonged to a wealthy banker who went insane, believing that someone was after his money. He was to have slaughtered his family before hanging himself. However, this story is only urban legend and is entirely false, with the Kukelhan family adamantly refuting these claims. Unfortunately, this version of the tale led to visitors vandalizing and damaging the property beyond repair, which ultimately required the mansion’s demolition in 2011.
All traces of the mansion have been removed. A new house has been built on the property and there have been no signs of paranormal activity since.